Zane,
My Marten hat is much more stylish than that furbag.....

.
Buck, Our efforts to extract more heat from my airplane sorta worked a little.
You contradicted yourself, by the way....In one sentence you said your engine runs warm, then you said it never gets up to 180 oil temps in winter. That is a big part of the problem, in my opinion.
The problem with the 170 (and Maules to some degree) is that they really need to have a cowl flap. There is a HUGE hole down there, creating a suction, to draw all that cold air in and through the engine cooling fins.
I hate putting tape out front. I'm always afraid of creating hot spots in the engine by causing turbulent flow over parts of the engine. I talked this over with Leroy Lopresti at one point and he agreed, as have a couple of Lycoming reps. They all agree that blocking off inlet intakes needs to be done intelligently (like a lot of the Lopresti mods) to create smooth air flow. They also agree that a cowl flap is the best way to deal with that, by limiting the flow on the back (suction) side. I know of a few 170's around FAI with a cowl flap, but I'd be surprised if you could get it field approved these days.
If I were to do it again, I'd consider putting the Power FLow exhaust on, which has a better, tighter heat shroud. I think you could tighten up the 170 shroud as well, and getting some ram air moving through there can't hurt either.
If you're willing to put duct tape across cowl openings, why would you worry about a snorkel sticking up blocking air flow? Just curious, I don't know what effect this might have, but it might work, and I don't know what it would do to air flow.
On my engine the #2 cylinder is the hottest, which is very counterintuitive, since its a forward cylinder.
I'm still working on it. I'm going pop riveting SS parts onto the heat muff on this thing soon.
MTV