Southern Boy wrote:Squash, MTV:
Agree with what you both said.
She is learning to fly, and it’s harder to maintain good airspeed control on short final and push on the stick...gets setup for a potentially difficult situation. (wish there was a cure for that setup on the Husky)
I really disagree with trimming so that a push is required just to maintain the proper pitch for the desired airspeed on final, especially for a student or low time pilot. The better practice is to trim to remove all pressure during the final leg--much easier to maintain the desired airspeed. With experience, we all learn work-arounds to make flying easier, and if trimming nose up on final works for an experienced pilot, fine and dandy. I wouldn't do it myself.
For myself, I don't find pushing easier than pulling; most people's arms have much stronger biceps than triceps, and mine sure do. In fact, for a low ground effect take off, I'll roll in a little nose down trim, which keeps the airplane from climbing out of ground effect as it gains airspeed, while I'm pulling gently on the yoke to maintain my 3 or 4 feet AGL. When I'm ready to climb, then I'll pitch to the climb attitude and trim to remove the pressure.
For a student or low time pilot, I don't think it's a good idea to trim any airplane into the flare, either--most have a hard enough time just being in trim on approach! Then the risk of a trim stall on a go around is too great, especially for newbies. That being said, trimming into the flare isn't a bad thing for those nose-heavy airplanes that require smallish folks to use both hands on the yoke/stick to make the flare, but being spring-loaded to roll off the aft trim in the event of a go around is essential.
Cary