Mon Jun 22, 2026 11:56 am
I watched as a Comanche very nearly went into the rocks at the south end of Big Creek one evening several years ago. The guy had never been into Big Creek before and didn't have any dual in canyon flying. He was instrument rated, though, and had plugged the coordinates for Big Creek into his GPS. (This was back when GPS in GA was new, and most airplanes weren't equipped.) He apparently didn't account for the waypoint being the midpoint of the runway, and approached at his regular flatland speed. There was a big cloud of dust as he locked up the mains and got nearly sideways, right up to within feet of the rocks and the line of parked cars at the south end by the lodge. The upslope saved him. I marveled that the gear didn't collapse.
What's crazy is that Big Creek and Johnson Creek are really long by backcountry standards. As long as they are, it's possible to abort and try another approach as long as you do it soon enough--and that's not when you're floating along in ground effect. At the risk of overgeneralizing, if you can't get down and stopped consistently and comfortably within 1,500' of the threshold with 50' tall trees, you have zero business going into any mountain strip in Idaho, and a lot of those strips require better performance/discipline than that.