Hangar flying...without the hangar,
Aviation lore is deep and wide. This discussion reminds me of ancient history reviewed in "Flying the Line". A marvelous book written about airline pilots and history going back to the dawn of commercial aviation.
Anyhow...back in the 1940s and early 50s there was a rageing debate about wheel landings or 3 point landings in the DC-3....among the pilots of Contintental Airlines. Now few of us would dare suggest that these early,pioneer, airline pilots were not "top notch" "stick and rudder" pilots. Few would debate that the DC-3 could be a "challenging" airplane or that these airmen flew them under difficult, and primative conditions.
Yet...even among that pilot group there was strenous disagreement. It seem that the CAL pilots based in Houston and flying throughtout the southwest favored the 3 point landing. The CAL pilots, who were based in the windy city of Chicago, insisted on wheel landings.
The debate ended when some Houston based captains were displaced to the Chicago domicile. Faced with winds and vis. not normally part of the sunny, southwest.....they quickly came to appreciate and understand the need to land the DC-3 on the main gear first. Eventually CAL joined the rest of the industry and made "wheel landings" mandatory.
Moral of this story is....use the technique that works for you, your airplane and the circumstance which you face at the moment.
With thousands of hours in conventional gear airplanes of many types.....I try to remain proficient in all techniques and chose the correct one for the circumstance. Sounds like that is what most experienced airmen do.
Let the debate continue forever. It is part of what makes our avocation/ vocation so much fun!
bob
p.s. The Houston based CAL pilots are the ONLY... DC-3 pilots whom I have ever encountered that practiced 3 point landings in a DC-3 or any other large tailwheel airplane for that matter.