I never understood this whole BMI thing... I'm a hardcore Marathoner/Triathlete Last year I ran 6 Marathons, 2 Ironman's and a boat load of half's and olympic/sprint tri's. I typically do two-a-day brick workouts 3 days a week, and single workouts lasting 1 to 1.5 hours the rest of the week. I generally stay well away from carbs and eat pretty healthy diet. My body fat % is usually in the 7-10% range... Not being arrogant, but i keep myself in pretty good shape!
Now the funny part... I went in for my physical last year (my 40th birthday present) and at the end the nurse looks at me and says "Unfortunately, you're clinically obese...", and then proceeds to hand me a package of information regarding diet and exercise. I thought she was kidding and laughed when she said it, but she was stone cold serious and had this look on her face like she was disgusted with me. I was speechless. Because I carry more muscle than the average person, I fall outside the "standard formula". What a joke.
I think this is an example of the government being the government.
Glad to see this potential new rule going down the path of the Dodo (because, after all, they are Dodo's!).
Jim
[EDIT: AND BTW... That freaken nurse could have stood to lose 30-40lbs... Her ass looked like two pit-bull's in a bag fighting]