Backcountry Pilot • Crash at Johnson Creek

Crash at Johnson Creek

Discuss your knowledge of airports and off-airport strips. Help inform other pilots of status, warnings, noise abatement, and closure endangerment. See also: http://www.shortfield.com
107 postsPage 4 of 61, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

It's a matter of attitude....bring a good one to all your flying, no matter where that flying occurs.


You touched on the one critical intangible that you can't list on a log book nor perceive on a web site. I know pilots, as all of us do, with thousands of hours that I would not fly with, and other with just a few hundred hours that I would enjoy and look forward to flying with. Attitude is a factor, but it's their decision making ability that separates the good and questionable for me, all other factors being equal. There are young pilots with low hours that seem to have the mature ability to make a sound, correct decision, and there are those pilots with thousands of hours that do stuff where we think, "What the hell were you thinking??"

I, for one, appreciate everyone's input on this site, as other's logic in their decision making is invaluable for those that haven't been faced with the situation that they have and shared.
Zenithguy offline
Supporter
User avatar
Posts: 215
Joined: Sun Aug 25, 2013 9:15 pm
Location: Newport Beach

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

Very well said Zenithguy.

Kurt
G44 offline
Supporter
User avatar
Posts: 2093
Joined: Thu Oct 27, 2011 10:46 am
Location: Michigan

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

G44 wrote:MTV nailed it!

Kurt


Yes, very well said MTV.
Zzz offline
Janitorial Staff
User avatar
Posts: 2855
Joined: Fri Oct 08, 2004 11:09 pm
Location: northern
Aircraft: Swiveling desk chair
Half a century spent proving “it is better to be thought a fool than to open your mouth and remove all doubt.”

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

Aviation, these day, for me is for relaxation and pure enjoyment. There is no sense of urgency when I plan a flight (unless weather or something goes wrong, which is really rare these days).

My interpretation of mainstream mega "Aviation Gathering" (AKA "Fly-ins")...

Mega-Fly-ins tend to have a sense of urgency or some type of arbitrary "closure" attached to them. To me the enjoyment of flying has continuity and flexibility. Being committed to dates, meetings, website threads and procedures is not why I fly. I like to meet up with people and friends but it tends to be very loosely organized.

I was extremely lucky being invited to a little fly-in downunder (Australia). About (6) Blokes went to lunch. It was loose but, I learned a great deal from those guys. The Australians are the real deal when it comes to bush (they certainly have enough of it). There are certainly many BCPs who have helped me GREATLY too but, not in such an overt fashion as attending a fly-in.

This website is fabulous, I feel very lucky to have joined. BCP.ORG is bigger than the sum, let's keep it that way! Keep the information and opinion flowing!
8GCBC offline
User avatar
Posts: 4623
Joined: Thu Aug 05, 2010 11:55 pm
Location: Honolulu
Aircraft: 2018 R44
CFII, MEI, CFISES, ATPME, IA/AP, RPPL, Ski&Amphib ops, RHC mechanic cert, RHC SC— 3000TT

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

The old suburban the pacer landed on. Image
OregonMaule offline
User avatar
Posts: 6977
Joined: Fri Sep 01, 2006 9:44 pm
Location: Orygun
My SPOT page

"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety". Ben Franklin
http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Benjamin_Franklin

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

OregonMaule wrote:The old suburban the pacer landed on. Image

Don't think that'll buff out. Shame :cry:

CW
clippwagon offline
User avatar
Posts: 737
Joined: Sun Nov 13, 2011 9:49 pm
Location: Oregon

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

are you at JC ROb?
iceman offline
User avatar
Posts: 2026
Joined: Sat Feb 17, 2007 8:01 am
Location: El Cajon Cal

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

clippwagon wrote:Don't think that'll buff out. Shame :cry:


True. But every bit of energy absorbed by that car is energy that didn't have to be absorbed by the pilot and his passenger.
rw2 offline
User avatar
Posts: 1799
Joined: Sat Dec 22, 2012 1:10 pm
Location: San Miguel de Allende
FindMeSpot URL: https://share.delorme.com/LaNaranjaDanzante
Aircraft: Experimental Maule
Follow my Flying, Cooking and Camping adventures at RichWellner.com

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

iceman wrote:are you at JC ROb?
yes with pops, Gary, and many more buds. Image
OregonMaule offline
User avatar
Posts: 6977
Joined: Fri Sep 01, 2006 9:44 pm
Location: Orygun
My SPOT page

"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety". Ben Franklin
http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Benjamin_Franklin

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

oh fine... and I won't get there till a week from this wed... have a marg for me... Hi Gary......just saw a video of Pops and his Ukelele hi to all... wish I was there... :lol:
iceman offline
User avatar
Posts: 2026
Joined: Sat Feb 17, 2007 8:01 am
Location: El Cajon Cal

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

OregonMaule wrote:
iceman wrote:are you at JC ROb?
yes with pops, Gary, and many more buds. Image


Whoa!! Awesome!! Dornier Do 28!!!
CapnMike offline
Supporter
User avatar
Posts: 842
Joined: Wed Mar 05, 2014 11:25 am
Location: Kamas, Utah and Sandpoint, Idaho
"If my wings should fail me Lord, please meet me with another pair" - Led Zeppelin
"It's all going in my report..." - CapnMike

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

CapnMike wrote:
OregonMaule wrote:
iceman wrote:are you at JC ROb?
yes with pops, Gary, and many more buds. Image


Whoa!! Awesome!! Dornier Do 28!!!


Rob, who ended up with the 28, I was really looking hard at that when a dose of reality set in!! Hate that!!
M6RV6 offline
User avatar
Posts: 2313
Joined: Mon Feb 25, 2008 5:52 pm
Location: Rice Wa. 82WN Magee Creek AERODROME
FindMeSpot URL: http://share.findmespot.com/shared/face ... sWKXuhKlg2
Have as much Fun as is Safe, and Keep SMILIN! GT,

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

M6RV6 wrote:
CapnMike wrote:
OregonMaule wrote:[quote="iceman"]are you at JC ROb?
yes with pops, Gary, and many more buds. Image


Whoa!! Awesome!! Dornier Do 28!!!


Rob, who ended up with the 28, I was really looking hard at that when a dose of reality set in!! Hate that!![/quote]Eric from Alabama. The guy with the white hair. He was the caretaker at JC in 07
OregonMaule offline
User avatar
Posts: 6977
Joined: Fri Sep 01, 2006 9:44 pm
Location: Orygun
My SPOT page

"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety". Ben Franklin
http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Benjamin_Franklin

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

For SpamCanFlier and any others:

Bob,

I would like to be able to fly with you sometime. I will be in Denver a few days this summer and at my troop's reunion 20-24 August at the Hotel Albuquerque in Old Town.

My boss at Underwood Aerial Patrol said I talk like I have marbles in my mouth. Many say I write the same way. I garble both forms of communication by jumping to what I happen to think about rather than organizing my thoughts, like MTV. Please ask questions when I confuse you.

My techniques are not new, just new to print. Some fall within the realm of "See no evil. Hear no evil. Speak no evil," for the training establishment. Instructors are under tremendous pressure to conform. That just didn't take with me, but they gave me a CFI before knowing how obnoxious I was. I joined the Army determined to become a famous general and that didn't go over so well either.

When I got a new student, I found out about his goals and past experience. Airplanes are simple machines and there are similarities with farm and construction equipment, motorcycles, etc. The language of other machines often transfers well.

Understand that while we old guys may have lots of experience, we are old and slow. We do not have flexible minds. New and different ideas sometimes hurt our pride. We are stubborn. Having less time for the government to mess with our lives, we tend to pay less attention to their threats.

Enough BS,

Jim

Contact
contactflying offline
Posts: 4972
Joined: Wed Apr 03, 2013 7:36 pm
Location: Aurora, Missouri 2H2
Download my free "https://tinyurl.com/Safe-Maneuvering" e-book.

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

So much wisdom and insight in this thread. I believe I speak for all the god-knows-how-many lurkers reading this thread, all of whom are gaining incredible wisdom and insight (and specifically, great motivation and reminder to be intentional about making every flight more precise and wiser then the last & to get more dual instruction!), when I say thank you to all the old farts, young farts, and everybody inbetween who shares wisdom here.

thank you!

someday, hopefully i can do the same!

best
dave
dpadvo offline
User avatar
Posts: 89
Joined: Mon Feb 23, 2015 1:00 am
Location: Kodiak

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

I had an exchange with an 80 year old CFI when I got home about this accident. First I must say I was not at Johnson Creek when it
happened but got in the next day. I told the CFI that there was one very bad accident by a low time pilot and his response was
that it was not because he was low time. In which I responded I thought he was wrong, we argued back and forth about it until I
gave up.

I know if all's I did from the 1st hour of flight until hour 150 was fly the backcountry of Idaho I might have just enough
experience to keep me safe going into J.C. heavy on a hot day with 200 people watching me. How many people have that narrow focus
starting out. Flying has never come natural to me like other forms of transportation has: snow machining, dirt biking, 4
wheeling/driving in snow and ice etc were easy for me to get the hang of. I have honed my skills through lots of practice and as
some of you know I'm still screwing up. I think my experience saved me from a very bad accident in September but I wrecked the
airplane.

I started flying Idaho when I was low time and at the time my log book probably said somewhere around 1000 hours... I managed to
keep the airplane in one piece for a while, got lucky a lot of times. I did a lot of things wrong the first few years I owned that
airplane until I finally wrecked it about killing me and my uncle in Eastern Oregon 1999. I was flying a M5-235c which I owned.
Density of altitude was the one that finally ended my lucky streak. I was flying low at 6000 feet MSL scouting for elk, I think
the density of altitude was calculated by the NTSB at around 9000 ft. when I tried to out climb rising terrain.

When we make these kinds of mistakes it all happens so quick that the choice to land and wreck the plane straight ahead vs stalling
and going in hard has passed. That has to be in the training which we really are not trained in wrecking a little vs wrecking BIG.
In hind sight I could have put the airplane down on the gravel road in front of me and been much better off, I would have still
probably broke a gear leg, got the propeller etc. but the airplane would have survived much better and I would not have been hurt.
One of the problems for me was I had this airplane that the power had never let me down. I had pulled off one other D.A. screw up
and the power saved the day. It was a hard lesson and one that could have been avoided but I had to learn it the hard way.

I feel for this guy but he just got his first hard lesson, what he does next time will make him a better pilot and for those that
have seen it I think it might make them better too. As for the passenger he is the one that really probably did not have any idea
how dangerous the flight to Idaho would be, I think we owe it to our passengers to be honest if the stakes are higher.

In reality he was probably landing a one way strip and did not realize it because of his lack of experience. Johnson Creek looks
so long until you are trying to claw your way back into the air with 80 horse power at 10k feet.

The some of all my experience makes me the pilot I am today. I don't think a 150 hour pilot has much experience in this three
dimensional world we live in but I am not going to tell him not to go to Johnson Creek. I would tell him that he has no idea how
many things could go wrong until he has some experience to draw from. The mistakes I have made mountain flying in the backcountry
and off airport have cost me more then the training would have cost to do it by taking specialized flying courses. That is one
thing I am sure of but would I do it different if I had it to do over again, I am not sure I would.

Think ahead of the airplane.

Greg
Mauleguy offline
User avatar
Posts: 217
Joined: Mon Dec 05, 2005 8:43 pm
Location: Washington

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

Mauleguy wrote:As for the passenger he is the one that really probably did not have any idea
how dangerous the flight to Idaho would be, I think we owe it to our passengers to be honest if the stakes are higher


Not to beat a dead horse, but this statement is key when we have passengers, and I'm always very aware of this when I fly with any other non-pilots, including my family.

Our passengers do not have the skill set required to make any kind of risk analysis regarding the flight. They blindly assume that if we say we're good to go, it must be so. It's a huge responsibility we have, and one that is sometimes overlooked, unfortunately.
Cannon offline
User avatar
Posts: 282
Joined: Wed Aug 28, 2013 7:17 pm
Location: SoCal
Aircraft: C-185
Piper J3C-65
Pitts S1S

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

Mauleguy wrote:I had an exchange with an 80 year old CFI when I got home about this accident. First I must say I was not at Johnson Creek when it
happened but got in the next day. I told the CFI that there was one very bad accident by a low time pilot and his response was
that it was not because he was low time. In which I responded I thought he was wrong, we argued back and forth about it until I
gave up.

I know if all's I did from the 1st hour of flight until hour 150 was fly the backcountry of Idaho I might have just enough
experience to keep me safe going into J.C. heavy on a hot day with 200 people watching me. How many people have that narrow focus
starting out. Flying has never come natural to me like other forms of transportation has: snow machining, dirt biking, 4
wheeling/driving in snow and ice etc were easy for me to get the hang of. I have honed my skills through lots of practice and as
some of you know I'm still screwing up. I think my experience saved me from a very bad accident in September but I wrecked the
airplane.

I started flying Idaho when I was low time and at the time my log book probably said somewhere around 1000 hours... I managed to
keep the airplane in one piece for a while, got lucky a lot of times. I did a lot of things wrong the first few years I owned that
airplane until I finally wrecked it about killing me and my uncle in Eastern Oregon 1999. I was flying a M5-235c which I owned.
Density of altitude was the one that finally ended my lucky streak. I was flying low at 6000 feet MSL scouting for elk, I think
the density of altitude was calculated by the NTSB at around 9000 ft. when I tried to out climb rising terrain.

When we make these kinds of mistakes it all happens so quick that the choice to land and wreck the plane straight ahead vs stalling
and going in hard has passed. That has to be in the training which we really are not trained in wrecking a little vs wrecking BIG.
In hind sight I could have put the airplane down on the gravel road in front of me and been much better off, I would have still
probably broke a gear leg, got the propeller etc. but the airplane would have survived much better and I would not have been hurt.
One of the problems for me was I had this airplane that the power had never let me down. I had pulled off one other D.A. screw up
and the power saved the day. It was a hard lesson and one that could have been avoided but I had to learn it the hard way.

I feel for this guy but he just got his first hard lesson, what he does next time will make him a better pilot and for those that
have seen it I think it might make them better too. As for the passenger he is the one that really probably did not have any idea
how dangerous the flight to Idaho would be, I think we owe it to our passengers to be honest if the stakes are higher.

In reality he was probably landing a one way strip and did not realize it because of his lack of experience. Johnson Creek looks
so long until you are trying to claw your way back into the air with 80 horse power at 10k feet.

The some of all my experience makes me the pilot I am today. I don't think a 150 hour pilot has much experience in this three
dimensional world we live in but I am not going to tell him not to go to Johnson Creek. I would tell him that he has no idea how
many things could go wrong until he has some experience to draw from. The mistakes I have made mountain flying in the backcountry
and off airport have cost me more then the training would have cost to do it by taking specialized flying courses. That is one
thing I am sure of but would I do it different if I had it to do over again, I am not sure I would.

Think ahead of the airplane.

Greg


It's awesome to hear (read?) someone with hard-won experience talking about the events they have experienced and their lessons learned the hard way.

It doesn't get any more credible than that......

Edit: In fact, Greg I bet your stories would make a great IMPACT sequel for this website.
"IMPACT II, The Re-Bending"
Last edited by Battson on Tue Jun 23, 2015 9:43 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Battson offline
Knowledge Base Author
User avatar
Posts: 1810
Joined: Wed May 09, 2012 11:19 pm
Location: New Zealand
Aircraft: Bearhawk 4-place
IO-540 260hp

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

I have been following this thread (and pretty much every other thread) pretty closely. The amount of information on this site is incredible. The amount of experience on this site makes for a great place for lurkers like me to learn. I don't often speak up because I don't feel that I have too much to contribute in the company of the many very experienced pilots that post on this board. I really appreciate the candid stories of crashes and near misses because there is so much to be gleaned from those experiences no matter how many hours and ratings you have.

In nearly 16 years in the Marine Corps, I have learned way more from things that I have f*#cked up or I have seen other people f@#ck up than I ever did in the myriad of formal schools that I have attended. Or in the laconic words of my old man, "I bet you won't do that again."

This post is really about tipping my hat to all of you out there that take the time to post and share your wisdom that can only be gained through experience. The topics posted on this board about accidents and near misses have undoubtedly saved lives and will continue to do so.

JB
Mojave Flyer offline
User avatar
Posts: 168
Joined: Sat Sep 27, 2014 2:06 pm
Location: Newport
Aircraft: Piper PA-28-180

Re: Crash at Johnson Creek

well since there are so many interrested in JC experiences I figure I'll retell the crashes I've seen in my many years of going up there... Maybe it will help shed some light on the difficulty of flying the mountains and canyons.... First or second year back in the 90's the sprinkler system was like the farmers use... long 4 inch pipes laid out on the runway with sprinkler heads every 40 or 50 feet... Gene and Cody were caretakers and we, my flying buds and I, offered to help with the job and it was a job laying all that pipe....we were almost done having started at the north end laying pipe on the west half of the runway so that aircraft could still land closer to the east side... we were about at the southern most outhouse when we heard a plane approaching from the North...we watched as he crossed the threshold about 75 ft above the grass.. it was a newly overhaulled turbo 182 flown by a midwest pilot and his wife as passenger... both were pilots... he added power at about the first runway distance marker but not enough to climb and go around... kept coming and stayed about 75 ft above the runway to the caretakers house and we began to wonder what his intentions were... there was no decent and when he got to our location we hightailed it to the trees as it was evident there was something not right.... at about 100 ft past the outhouse he stalled and slammed it on flat and went back up about 35 ft rolled left and nosed into the runway about a hundred feet from the parking area... turns out they were arguing about what to do .. He wanted to salvage the landing she was yelling go around..so in this instance pilot distraction was probably a major factor... we got them out and both were shaken but unhurt... vacation over...next one was a couple years later... a new low time pilot in, if I remember correctly, a 125 HP grumman T cat... loaded and afternoon... wind naturally out of the south so he made the decision to take off to the south,,, several pilots advised him that was not a good idea and urged him to wait till evening when wind shifted and lessened.... he waited about an hour and launched to the south.... flew around the house at tree top level and wound up in the creek upstream... Third was a newly overhauled 210 with 5 hrs since overhaul when pilot decided to venture off to the mountains... entered down wind on the south side at well over the tops of the ridges... turned base and final about a mile from the runway same altitude... turned final and realized how high he was so he pointed the nose at the ground and dove... no shit we were looking at the top of the aircraft as if we were directly above it on the ground... well all that speed built up and he rounded out about 20 feet above the grass doing about 90... then tried to force it on whereby it bounced, and he tried it again, this time the nose wheel departed and we all once again hastily left the shade of our parked planes and ran... he wound up in the trees on the west side by the wind sock...third was a twin that couldn't get airborn in the heat of the afternoon g oing North... wound up in the tall grass down by the old mink farm....fourth was a piper 140 loaded and trying to take off to the north again after noon,... we and several others advised him to wait as he was asking advice.... advice ignored and we watched him clip a tree at the end but luckily kept going... he made it to McCall....didn't see the one during a BCP fly in years ago but there was a pilot new to mountain flying wanting to go to big creek for breakfast... turned up the wrong canyon after yellow pine and found it was a box canyon... not enough room to turn, didn't practice canyon turns i gather, not enough altitude and not knowing what to look for in the drainages....he didn't make it but his wife did....so low time not withstanding decisions were made in spite of advice from knowlegable pilots familiar with the mountains, diving to an airport... ( my old instructor told me you don't dive to an airport. if that's your choice to land you've already fucked up your approach and probably will the landing, or arrival , as he called it...taking off with a underpowered aircraft for the conditions into rising terrain, failure to see your no go abort point...flying down the middle of the canyons instead of high and to the right, I don't know I remember being tought all those things when I was a low time student... and I am sure all those CFI"s mentioned those things at least once during their training of these guys.. so what do we do about the galactically stupid... hopefully don't occupy the same airspace as them but better yet, be doubly vigilant in the mountains and if you want to do this kind of flying more than once get some dual from a local or local instructor...hope I haven't pissed anyone off again....lol
iceman offline
User avatar
Posts: 2026
Joined: Sat Feb 17, 2007 8:01 am
Location: El Cajon Cal

DISPLAY OPTIONS

PreviousNext
107 postsPage 4 of 61, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests

Latest Features

Latest Knowledge Base