Skalywag wrote:ABWs n 29X11x10 are comparing apples n oranges. The ABW give a plane air ride shocks and save the airframe from a ton of abuse if landing on rough stuff. If it saved me $2000 a year having 29X11X10 instead of ABW it would still be an easy choice for me, ABW are just that much better. Anyone checked the cost of Cessna parts lately, shock absorbion is the whole deal with ABW to me, we are talking about 50-60+ year old airplanes here, give them all the help they can get if ur an off airport flyer.
Even on somewhat improved grass strips I thought were pretty smooth with Bushwheels, I've been shocked how rough they were with the 29X11X10 or 8.50s. It's night and day.
If it was a choice between 8.50s n 29X11X10 I'd go with the 8.50s for what I do, because with neither of them would I continue to land on the moderately to really rough stuff. Now if it was someone else's plane I was getting paid to fly n they paid the maintenance bills n told me to go for it, well that's a different story I guess...
As I noted it all depends on your mission!! Should I repeat that a couple dozen times?
I've landed in stuff it's tough to walk in with the 29 x 11 x 10 tires.....but this was beaches and soft stuff....not very rough, but lots of floatation needed. They worked well.
But, as you note, if you're landing in rock piles with BIG rocks, there is no question the Bushwheels are a far better choice. Any size Bushwheels are a better choice, but the bigger and squishier, the better. As others have noted, I think the 29 inch ABW is a good choice for the Cessnas.
Now, that said, frankly, the vast majority of Bushwheel wearing airplanes land exclusively at airports......and occasionally a "backcountry" airport or two.
You are obviously the exception to that statement, and there's little doubt that the Bushwheels are the best choice for you. You're right there is a big difference in the performance of the tires
in their element.
As to damage to airframes from landings, I hate to break this to you, but if you really are landing in places that are as rough as you say, there's a good chance you're going to damage the airframe in any case, regardless of the tires you're running. It's kind of like four wheel drive.....it can let you get in REALLY deep before you get stuck, or break something. And, tires only go so far in protecting the airframe......
Nothing wrong with that...please don't take that as suggesting a condemnation--it's your plane and your checkbook. These things will land in some pretty amazing stuff, indeed. But, like all off airport operations, you have to go into the operation with the understanding that at some point, you have a really good shot at damaging or destroying the airplane....that's the nature of the beast.
Most folks aren't going to get in that deep, but a 29 x 11 x 10 tire will roll right over a gopher hole that's strategically located in a backcountry strip. And THAT can save a lot of damage to the airframe. 99 % of the time, an 8.50 x 6.00 tire would have worked fine on that strip....till you get unlucky that once. So, it's all a matter of degree.
But, again, it's all about the mission, and the 29 x 11 x10 tires work VERY well in a variety of challenging environments. In my case, about 60% of landings were on pavement, but the rest were rough strips and gravel bars.
You're correct that the Bushwheels absorb a lot of abuse, but they really don't like pavement, and they are incredibly expensive. I would respectfully note that ABW went to a great deal of expense and time to engineer, develop and STC their ten inch wheels for these airplanes, just so they could run the 29 x 11 x 10 tires......wonder why these pretty smart guys who sell those Bushwheels felt there was also a niche for these tires?
Oh, yeah, I forgot, it's also a lot about the "cool" factor. And, again, there's nothing wrong with that. Lots of big tires never leave the pavement, but then again, lots of airplanes never leave the hangar. So what?
Choose what works for you, but there's a lot of places where the 29 x 11 x 10 tires will do the job safely and efficiently, without contributing to damage to the airframe. It only takes one overzealous rodent to ruin your day and your plane.......
It's all about the mission.
MTV