Just wrote this email to Dr. Colman:
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Dear Dr. Colman:
I understand from Internet reports [link to BCP and Cliff Mass blog removed] that the National Weather Service is considering closing its Stampede Pass weather station and moving it to Snoqualmie Pass for budgetary reasons. I am writing to urge the National Weather Service to reconsider that choice.
I am a pilot in Seattle with family in Eastern Washington. I have crossed the Cascades many times in my Cessna Skywagon, which was manufactured in 1977 and has been flying consistently since then. Even though I am instrument rated and my airplane has been equipped with the latest avionics, I will typically be unable to fly through the Cascades in clouds because of the risk of the water in those clouds’ turning to ice on my aircraft. Therefore, I rely on the information from the Stampede Pass ASOS to inform me of cloud heights. High winds in the Cascades can also be of concern to general aviation due to rotor effects as strong winds cross the pass, which effects can overpower most general aviation small aircraft.
You might ask why the information about cloud heights and wind wouldn’t be just as effective coming from Snoqualmie Pass as from Stampede Pass. Two reasons come to mind. First is that Stampede Pass is at a higher elevation than Snoqualmie, so that the cloud height (measured from the weather station) will be more indicative of the general cloud cover over that area of the Cascades. Second is that Stampede Pass, unlike Snoqualmie Pass, is pretty much a straight line from Seattle to Ellensburg. That might not seem like such a big deal except that most small general aviation aircraft are quite underpowered when flying at elevations necessary to cross the Cascades due to the decrease air pressure at altitude. With a straight course, the pilot is in a pretty good position to see ahead what the weather is looking like and to turn around if prudent. When one is flying through a curving pass, like Snoqualmie, the view is obstructed if you are flying in the pass and you may have to execute a turn when you encounter lower ceilings. While good training can help pilots to understand how to safely make a small radius turn by flying slowly, many pilots feel that they may be turning too slowly (coming to grief with some hard mountain sides) and may try to tighten up their turn, which can lead to their aircraft stalling and potentially crashing into the terrain.
I have copied other pilots that I know on this email so that, if they agree that closing the Stampede Pass station would be detrimental to aviation, they might be able to add their voices to mine.
Regards,
Greg Gorder