flylow wrote:I’m sold on skis over snowshoes. I’ve been using the Altai Hoks - fat skis. They are faster than snowshoes to pack down an area.
I've been using those too, but I'm not entirely sold on them. I find them better than snowshoes some places (much more efficient in flat or gently rolling terrain), and worse than snowshoes other places. Though admittedly, I have no talent as a skier in steep terrain, and I've never tried using them to pack down a airstrip. Transporting them does pose more of a logistical problem...longer and heavier than snowshoes.
The original tube-n-platform snowshoe was the Sherpa Snowclaw, and they made some fairly big models...much bigger than anything made today. I see them in second hand stores every now and again, and if the decking and lacing is still in serviceable condition (most of them are about 30 years old at this point) they are a good deep-powder option.
Almost every snowshoe I've seen on the market in the past decade is both ridiculously heavy and lacking in the flotation needed for powder snow, or for a heavy person carrying a pack. Many of them are just worthless unless you're on groomed snow.
The snowshoes I like are Northern Lites Tundra, in part because they weigh very little (24 ounces each) and you can put them on in a few seconds. They are also fairly narrow, so a somewhat normal gate is possible.

They don't have the flotation of the 5' cross country snowshoes, but they have more flotation than any of the other tube snowshoes I've seen, and there's no maintenance or warping or mildewing. They're also tough...I've used them for years in a variety of nasty conditions without anything other than cosmetic scratches as a result.
One place where snowshoes excel over skis, regardless of how much talent one might have as a skier, is in cutting firewood and poles and making a camp in deep snow. The maneuverability of snowshoes and the ability to work right in front of your feet makes pitching camp much easier, especially in snow conditions where it's impossible to move around without something for flotation. I tried cutting firewood while wearing Hoks...it wasn't at all satisfactory.