Backcountry Pilot • Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

Discuss the legality of flying the backcountry, FARs, advocacy, and aviation relevant legislation. Registered users only.
70 postsPage 3 of 41, 2, 3, 4

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

S-12Flyer wrote: Most fatal heart attacks are sudden and incapacitating.
Does this mean that most fatal heart attack patients have no idea what-so-ever that they are in bad shape? I would trust your assessment on this. I dunno. I always though you got that nausea, left arm pain, chest pressure, sweating profusely, angina sort of thing. I do know that some fatal heart attacks, especially amongst younger men give little warning. I had a friend go that way at age 48. Poor slob. He left behind a beautiful widow and a healthy estate though. :roll:

Given the choice I would have preferred to be a charred grease stain at the bottom of an aerobatic box to the way he left the planet.

In my family we die of the big C or just fade away into a drooling doorstop. Not much danger of taking anyone with me with either of those fates.
Mister701 offline
User avatar
Posts: 2134
Joined: Thu Dec 05, 2013 11:13 pm
Location: Sparks
Aircraft: Rans S7LS

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

Emory Bored wrote:
S-12Flyer wrote: Most fatal heart attacks are sudden and incapacitating.
Does this mean that most fatal heart attack patients have no idea what-so-ever that they are in bad shape? I would trust your assessment on this. I dunno. I always though you got that nausea, left arm pain, chest pressure, sweating profusely, angina sort of thing. I do know that some fatal heart attacks, especially amongst younger men give little warning.

That would be great if most people didn't ignore the warnings. Heartburn, stress, sore muscles, one too many chili dogs, all sorts of reasons for the pain. A lot of victims know they are at risk but think that it won't happen to them. Many however have no idea. That's why the call hypertension "the silent killer". By the time you get the arm pain and the crushing chest pain, you better be close to a first responder.
S-12Flyer offline
User avatar
Posts: 534
Joined: Wed Jan 12, 2011 11:11 am
Location: Grand Junction, CO
"In a world full of people, only a few want to fly"

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

A friend of mine and I were talking about this the other day, he would like to go LSA after a heart attack. My suggestion was why doesn't the FAA handle it the same as they do Experimental or Restricted category aircraft. Just put a placard on the entry door(s) that the pilot does not meet FAA 3rd class medical standards. That leaves it up to the passenger to decide for themselves if the are willing to assume the risk. As for the risk to persons and property on the ground there are a multitude of potential causes for an aircraft hitting something or someone on the ground, and often times an aircraft which hits the ground hits neither, starting with fuel exhaustion or mechanical failure and going from there. Of course I know this would not work as it requires a willingness to take personal responsibility, hard to find often times now days.

Tim
bat443 offline
Supporter
User avatar
Posts: 431
Joined: Thu Mar 30, 2006 11:37 am
Location: northern LP of MI

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

There are FAR bigger problems out there than qualified pilots driving airplanes around:


As reported by an ABC news affiliate in South Bend, Indiana, a woman named Bonnie Miller fell into a river connected to Lake Michigan while she was attempting to walk along a pier and send a text message at the same time. Miller was strolling along the pier with her family and realized that she had to correct an appointment time via a text message. As she was writing the text message, Miller didn’t pay attention to how close she was to the edge of the pier and ending up tripping into approximately six feet of cold water. #-o

Oh, and nothing about this proposal allows one to fly with a known disqualifying medical condition. All it does is take the bureaucrat out of the middle. Your friend who's had the heart attack needs to get the problem corrected (angioplasty, bypass, something) before considering LSA.
Mister701 offline
User avatar
Posts: 2134
Joined: Thu Dec 05, 2013 11:13 pm
Location: Sparks
Aircraft: Rans S7LS

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

Emory you know that, and I know that, and I believe that he knows that. He knows that the procedure he had, an implanted defibrillator following his heart attack is disqualifying, just in denial, trying to ignore the part about a known disqualifying condition. I know that he will never go LSA, just not ready to admit to himself that after several decades of an airline career he was done the day he had the heart attack. Hasn't flown in 3 years, started at home on the tread mill and had the cardiac arrest in the ER. Hard for him to give up such a big part of his life. It is unfortunate that AOPA is telling pilots like him that if you have a drivers license and have not failed a medical you are good to go LSA.

Tim
bat443 offline
Supporter
User avatar
Posts: 431
Joined: Thu Mar 30, 2006 11:37 am
Location: northern LP of MI

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

What I believe also needs to be mentioned is that we who truly love and live aviation are in a state of war, and currently fighting a losing battle for our way of life. What would have been debatable, or discussable on an academic level several years ago has become "desperate times" today. Everything we do in aviation has a hell of a lot more riding on it than ever before.

When the FAR's and medical rules were written, aviation could afford to "discard" people. I'm sincerely sorry to say it that way, but in the 1970's the idea of 500 pilots not being able to fly because of a failed medical was acceptable... "gotta follow the rules for safety there, boys..." and there were 500 more kids (like me) taking flying lessons to replace the 500 we lost.

Today, if we lose 500 pilots, we're down 500 voters, we're down 500 paying hangar renters, on and on.

So I feel like I gotta to throw a reality check up in everyone's face: Statistics clearly show that (as mentioned) it's a very very small risk of a medical-related crash flying with a driver's license, and zero actual incidents in recent years since Sport Pilot / LSA. On the other hand there is a very large gain to be made for every older pilot we keep, and every new pilot we get, for whatever reason they are kept or gotten.

This is a numbers game... how many pilots, pro-aviation voters, and airport supporters there are to fight against the overwhelmingly vast numbers of don't care's, and anti-noisers, and user fee'ers, and real estate vermin, and cockroach city council members, etc. etc.

If we have one or two crashes due to medical problems, for every 10,000 pilots we keep or get, well... I'm sorry to sound like Curtis LeMay here, but that is the cost of winning a war. I don't want to see anyone pop a cork inflight and crash, and yes it would bring bad publicity to this issue, but having aviation become any more marginalized than it already probably costs us far worse.

Make the self-cert as safe as you can make it, find some kind of deterrent against people lying or "pencil-whipping" their self-cert (like liability that passes on to their grandkids or something), and then get to work putting more people in the air.
EZFlap offline
User avatar
Posts: 2226
Joined: Thu Aug 13, 2009 9:21 am
.

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

Emory Bored wrote:.... it does what all administrative law does, it builds a fortress, and then protects and grows that fortress to it's dying day. I think Reagan said it best; "The closest thing to eternal life we have in this world is a government program." EB


Off topic, but this (and the corn growers & distillers lobbies) is why we're gonna have a helluva tme getting rid of the ethanol-in-gas program now that it's entrenched.
hotrod180 offline
Supporter
User avatar
Posts: 10534
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 11:47 pm
Location: Port Townsend, WA
Cessna Skywagon -- accept no substitute!

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

Zane wrote:........The most difficult thing we do as pilots is to self-assess, whether it's personal limits of experience and ability, or our medical fitness to command a 1 ton fuel-filled 120mph missile possibly loaded with non-pilot passengers. Medical self-certification is a concept that I equate to simply writing off the whole concept of medical evaluation. .....
I'm not sure I could remain objective if I had to self-certify my medical condition and make the go/no-go decision.....


A medical certificate is like a used car, the warranty is good right until you walk out the door. We're *already* self-certifying that our physical condition is sufficiently OK to operate our aircraft, every time we fly.
As far as being able to do damage, both of my 2 modest cars weigh more than my 1760# loaded to the gills C150/150. And bombing down the highway at 60mph or more within a couple feet of other vehicles doing the same, I'm a lot more likely to cause that damage if I become suddenly incapacitated than when flying my spamcan in the "big sky" environment.
hotrod180 offline
Supporter
User avatar
Posts: 10534
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 11:47 pm
Location: Port Townsend, WA
Cessna Skywagon -- accept no substitute!

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

Zane wrote:....There was a well known Rogue valley pilot named Bill Warren who recently headed west. He had just spent a great day flying, and passed away from heart failure on his deck that evening. He apparently maintained a medical right to the very end, teaching people to fly, even after having had previous issues with his heart......


A perfect example why 3rd class medical certificates are NOT really doing much for safety.
BTW Bill Warren spent a summer in Port Townsend many years ago doing flight instruction -- I never flew with him but by all reports he was an excellent stick & a great instructor, esp for aerobatics. He owned a 450 Stearman then, the "Warren Meteor", but did most of his instructing in a C150 Aerobat operated by my friend's flight school.
hotrod180 offline
Supporter
User avatar
Posts: 10534
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 11:47 pm
Location: Port Townsend, WA
Cessna Skywagon -- accept no substitute!

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

Emory Bored wrote:....They were not in a condition that I would consider airworthy if it were me. Pale, short of breath, tire easily, pain in the extremities, insomnia.. .....


Uh oh. #-o
hotrod180 offline
Supporter
User avatar
Posts: 10534
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 11:47 pm
Location: Port Townsend, WA
Cessna Skywagon -- accept no substitute!

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

Anyone see this?

http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5hK8u0JI-CYjGe4b48FwP4Mxjo5LQ?docId=13a11751a8b744d5bfd5ba5f1059263c

Associated Press wrote:Woman, 80, lands plane on low fuel; husband dies
By CARRIE ANTLFINGER, Associated Press

MILWAUKEE (AP) — An 80-year-old woman with little flying experience knew her husband had died after he fell unconscious at the controls of a small plane, yet she remained calm as she landed the aircraft at a northeastern Wisconsin airport, her son said Tuesday.

In a phone interview with The Associated Press, James Collins said he's also a pilot and had helped his mother Helen Collins via radio as the Cessna twin-engine plane began running out of gas Monday evening. Another pilot also took to the skies to guide her to the ground at Cherryland Airport, near Sturgeon Bay — about 150 miles north of Milwaukee.

He said his mother took lessons to take off and land about 30 years ago at her husband's urging, in case something happened to him, but never got her license. She has flown hundreds of hours by his side.

"At one point she didn't even want the wingman to go up," he said. "She said, 'Don't you guys think I could do this on my own? Don't you have confidence in me?' She was calmer than everybody on the ground. She had it totally under control."

They were coming back from their second home in Marco Island, Fla. for Easter, Collins said. His 81-year-old father, John Collins, had a heart attack about seven minutes from landing at Cherryland Airport and had called for her before he became unconscious, Collins said. She had called 911 and that's when everyone came together to help her down.

The pilot who helped was Robert Vuksanovic, who lived just a mile from the airport, said Keith Kasbohm, director of Cherryland Airport. After getting the call from Kasbohm, Vuksanovic jumped in another plane owned by the Collins and flew up to meet the Cessna while instructing the novice on the radio.

"He felt it would be easier," Kasbohm said. "With him alongside of her he could control her speed and altitude" before she attempted a landing.

Collins said his mother knew her husband had died after she unsuccessfully tried to get him back into his seatbelt, which he unbuckled before he collapsed.

He said one engine had completely run out of gas and the other had to be close to running out because it was sputtering. The nose-wheel collapsed upon landing and she skidded down the runway about 1,000 feet, but she worked the rudders to keep the plane straight.

"The amazing thing is she landed that plane on one engine," Collins said. "I don't know if there are a lot of trained pilots that could do that."

At a news conference Tuesday, Vuksanovic said he also experienced Helen Collins' confidence, WLUK-TV reported.
"She wanted to know if I was confident in her confidence," he said. "I said if you're confident then I'm confident, I think we can do this."

Collins said his mother was hospitalized on Tuesday with an injury to her vertebrae and a cracked rib but was doing well.
He said he stayed calm and focused because he had to help her.

"I already knew I lost my dad, I didn't want to lose my mom," he said. "It could have been both of them at once."

Collins described his mother's actions as unbelievable, answering their questions about air speed or the flaps. "You think she had done it all her life."

"Everybody is proud of her," he said. "I think she is a local hero for sure."

Torry Lautenbach, whose property is next to the airport, watched her land and estimated she circled the airport about 10 times.

"She did a really good job (landing the plane). It was amazing," Lautenbach said. "It took one bad hop and then it came back down and skidded."

Elizabeth Isham Cory, a spokeswoman with the Federal Aviation Administration, said John Collins had a current private pilot's license but couldn't immediately provide any details on how often he needed to get a medical exam. She said pilots can fly until they stop passing medical exams.

The Collins family, of Sturgeon Bay, own a small manufacturing company in Door County, authorities said. John Collins founded C & S Manufacturing in 1962, according to the company's website.
Zzz offline
Janitorial Staff
User avatar
Posts: 2854
Joined: Fri Oct 08, 2004 11:09 pm
Location: northern
Aircraft: Swiveling desk chair
Half a century spent proving “it is better to be thought a fool than to open your mouth and remove all doubt.”

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

Yeah, and I bet he had a valid medical....

Gump
GumpAir offline
User avatar
Posts: 4557
Joined: Wed Feb 14, 2007 9:14 am
Location: Lost somewhere in Nevada
Aircraft: Old Clunker

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

GumpAir wrote:Yeah, and I bet he had a valid medical....

Gump


I bet you're right.

Just a reminder that the most important thing is to be honest with yourself about your fitness to fly. No governing agency can do that for you regardless the regulations.

Then, sometimes, shit just happens.
Zzz offline
Janitorial Staff
User avatar
Posts: 2854
Joined: Fri Oct 08, 2004 11:09 pm
Location: northern
Aircraft: Swiveling desk chair
Half a century spent proving “it is better to be thought a fool than to open your mouth and remove all doubt.”

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

Just read this on AOPA.org., "The FAA opened its official comment period June 12 for an exemption to third class medical certificate regulations filed jointly by AOPA and the Experimental Aircraft Association (EAA). Supporters have only 20 days—until July 2—to submit comments, which is shorter than the usual 30- or 60-day period established for comments."

Not sure how this differs from the comment period that began in March. More details at the link below

http://www.aopa.org/advocacy/articles/2 ... ption.html

Regards, Lefty
Lefty offline
User avatar
Posts: 21
Joined: Sat Oct 29, 2011 11:23 am
Location: Portland, OR
"It's not your takeoffs, they're fine.......it's your landings that are scaring everybody"

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

Just submitted a comment (second time, hope they allow me to vote like an ACORN voter... early and often).

We need this to go through, please take the time to do it even if you qualify for a medical. Some of your friends probably ned the help to keep flying even if you don't.
EZFlap offline
User avatar
Posts: 2226
Joined: Thu Aug 13, 2009 9:21 am
.

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

Yes guys....please send in a comment no matter how you feel this may affect you. I wrote a response on the EAA forums to a guy that thinks this should not be approved. The guy really pissed me off!! Funny how someone that is in perfect health thinks they will forever stay that way and that they are above it all.
We need to keep everyone flying to continue flying and to be ambassadors for our way of life. Losing too many pilots yearly and pretty soon there will be no one to fight for our cause.
The younger generation sees it as an almost impossibly achievable goal due to the costs and hassles involved with flying. The ones that are achieving their dream are generally sons/daughters of pilots and we need new blood.
Time to get off my soapbox.
WWhunter offline
Supporter
User avatar
Posts: 2036
Joined: Sat Apr 02, 2005 1:54 pm
Location: Minnesota
Aircraft: RANS S-7
Murphy Rebel
VANS RV-8

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

New commit submitted

G'Day
OregonMaule offline
User avatar
Posts: 6977
Joined: Fri Sep 01, 2006 9:44 pm
Location: Orygun
My SPOT page

"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety". Ben Franklin
http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Benjamin_Franklin

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

EZFlap wrote: Just submitted a comment (second time, hope they allow me to vote like an ACORN voter... early and often).....


Me too, not too sure how we were able to comment earlier, prior to the official comment period.
I posted about this the other day on the pacificnorthwestflying site urging everyone to comment, and one of the people there said he'd rather give up flying than have the 50nm "leash" of the recreational pilot license. Well, I differ on giving up, but he was incorrect about that leash. Although the new proposed limitations mimic those of the recreational license, the 50nm leash & uncontrolled airspace-only aspects of recreational pilot are NOT part of it. And even if you do hold a recreational pilot certificate, the range & airspace limitations can be eliminated with additional training per FAR 61.101 (c) & (d).
hotrod180 offline
Supporter
User avatar
Posts: 10534
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 11:47 pm
Location: Port Townsend, WA
Cessna Skywagon -- accept no substitute!

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

Damm, that pisses me off. Yeh if you have a rec pilot ticket you have restrictions, if you have a private pilots lic it dosen't matter what you fly, you have all the privliges of a private pilot. Day,night,VFR,IFR,altitude. You're only restricted by your license, not your ride.
Magnet offline
User avatar
Posts: 362
Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2010 12:13 pm
Location: Albuquerque
Magnet

Re: Request for Exemption of Class III medical filed today!!

Magnet wrote:Damm, that pisses me off. Yeh if you have a rec pilot ticket you have restrictions, if you have a private pilots lic it dosen't matter what you fly, you have all the privliges of a private pilot. Day,night,VFR,IFR,altitude. You're only restricted by your license, not your ride.
Nope! Read it again. Day, VFR, less than 1321lbs, stall speed and top speed restrictions, pilot and passenger only, two seats etc. regardless of rating.
Mister701 offline
User avatar
Posts: 2134
Joined: Thu Dec 05, 2013 11:13 pm
Location: Sparks
Aircraft: Rans S7LS

DISPLAY OPTIONS

PreviousNext
70 postsPage 3 of 41, 2, 3, 4

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests

Latest Features

Latest Knowledge Base