aktahoe1 wrote:Dave had a hard time with the Penetration skis. Curious if anyone else is running these and your take on them. No disrespect to them, but they seem not really proficient.
Welcome to the wonderful world of penetration skis

The penetration skis are a COMPROMISE. A BIG one. They do not in any way compare to either straight skis or even retractable skis. All the power in the world won't help much.
I landed the other day with my wheels down on my hydraulics skis purely out of curiosity and had more drag than I can even relate. Talk about a short field landing... Got stuck real quick in 6 inches of snow. Pumped the skis down and I was off.
So my question, why do they even make these. Seems like you can use big tires in the same conditions that the pen skis are getting into. Thoughts?
The answer is simple: People want to be able to operate on pavement and snow both, and didn't come equipped with unlimited $$$$$ (or simply have other priorities). The difference in price between retractables and penetration skis in the certified world is about triple the price.
After we made umpteen dozen laps in the track to pack it down he could finally get off, and he is running a 550 in the machine. Laps were literally 1.5 miles long at 6500'. The hydraulics were up and out in less than 800' in the fresh untracked with 2 pax and 35 gallons of fuel. Again, curious of your thoughts on the penetration skis. The little tail wheel in the back of the skis just makes no sense to me.
If you get into this situation again, make sure you take some tools along, and REMOVE those miserable little tail springs/wheels from the ski tails. Now, take off. You will not BELIEVE how much drag those little tail wheels create in the snow.
And, by the way, what you have pictured here is distinctly NOT deep snow. Deep snow is when you get out of the airplane, and sink to your armpits in the snow. You're right, in those conditions, you MIGHT be able to land with wheels alone, depending on snow texture. But, get in three feet of snow, and those penetration skis WILL outperform wheels a good bit....
Don't forget that at 6,500 feet, those engines aren't making anywhere near full rated power, either. Granted, the lower temps help a little, but that 300 hp engine in the 185 isn't making any 300 hp.
Penetration skis are a compromise. If you're in really deep snow, they're better than wheels. They are a great way to get stuck, however. If you get in REALLY deep stuff, it is possible to flatten the tires and shove a plate under the tire to block the wheel opening in the ski. This is like a last ditch effort, though, and requires you to find another, shallower snow place to land and inflate the tires (you do carry a pump, right????). In other words, a PITA.
Note that Landes has redesigned those tail wheels on their penetration skis. I have HEARD that the new design is much better from a drag perspective, but I'm not sure they're a direct replacement. ANYthing would be an improvement over those original tail wheels, though. Again, get stuck, remove the tail wheel assemblies (including the springs) from the skis, takeoff and find someplace with less snow to land and replace the wheels, or land on a runway and grind a little bit of your ski off....
MTV