Good chance the magnet has lost strength, I've read they can be remagnetized but haven't attempted myself nor sent out to a shop that could.
We had a dead gauge on our 54, ended up just replacing it with a new rochester
https://www.aircraftspruce.com/catalog/inpages/mech_fuel_gauge.phpNew one is readable for sure - but per my definition I'm not sure I'd say it "works." I'm a stickler on dipping the tanks every flight.
Eventually we'll replace some/all of the panel in this plane, and will go CEIS at that point.