Fri Mar 23, 2012 12:04 am
What I believe also needs to be mentioned is that we who truly love and live aviation are in a state of war, and currently fighting a losing battle for our way of life. What would have been debatable, or discussable on an academic level several years ago has become "desperate times" today. Everything we do in aviation has a hell of a lot more riding on it than ever before.
When the FAR's and medical rules were written, aviation could afford to "discard" people. I'm sincerely sorry to say it that way, but in the 1970's the idea of 500 pilots not being able to fly because of a failed medical was acceptable... "gotta follow the rules for safety there, boys..." and there were 500 more kids (like me) taking flying lessons to replace the 500 we lost.
Today, if we lose 500 pilots, we're down 500 voters, we're down 500 paying hangar renters, on and on.
So I feel like I gotta to throw a reality check up in everyone's face: Statistics clearly show that (as mentioned) it's a very very small risk of a medical-related crash flying with a driver's license, and zero actual incidents in recent years since Sport Pilot / LSA. On the other hand there is a very large gain to be made for every older pilot we keep, and every new pilot we get, for whatever reason they are kept or gotten.
This is a numbers game... how many pilots, pro-aviation voters, and airport supporters there are to fight against the overwhelmingly vast numbers of don't care's, and anti-noisers, and user fee'ers, and real estate vermin, and cockroach city council members, etc. etc.
If we have one or two crashes due to medical problems, for every 10,000 pilots we keep or get, well... I'm sorry to sound like Curtis LeMay here, but that is the cost of winning a war. I don't want to see anyone pop a cork inflight and crash, and yes it would bring bad publicity to this issue, but having aviation become any more marginalized than it already probably costs us far worse.
Make the self-cert as safe as you can make it, find some kind of deterrent against people lying or "pencil-whipping" their self-cert (like liability that passes on to their grandkids or something), and then get to work putting more people in the air.
.