Mon Dec 01, 2014 10:03 pm
A couple of months ago I departed a friend's place in my 185. Climbed to about 8,500 feet, leveled off, and then the unmistakable smell of burning electrics greeted my nose. Prepared to turn off the master, I glanced at the circuit breakers and looked around the cabin for smoke. In short order the smell dissipated. I continued on to my airport and once on the ground took a closer look at the breakers. The one for the transponder was popped. I pushed it in, turned on the master, then the transponder and in a couple of seconds the breaker popped again. I pulled the transponder, pushed the breaker back in, and switched on the master again. Breaker held so I tossed the transponder in the nearest trash can (it had been repaired once already) and installed a new one.
Never push a breaker back in during flight, not ever. And absolutely never hold the breaker in while its trying to trip, not in the air and not on the ground, thats an invitation to a fire you can't stop. And here's why: Most of us are flying aircraft that were built before yesterday, and that almost guarantees that some hack has wired stuff incorrectly as things have been added and removed from the aircraft. When I refurbished the 185 not one circuit breaker actually was protecting the circuit it was labeled for, and that means that amperage it was protecting was incorrect. On top of that, the 185 didn't come with a lot of circuit breakers to begin with so each circuit breaker incorrectly protected lots of things, again with incorrect amperage. And if that wasn't enough, aircraft wiring is sized to pass a certain amount of amps, and almost certainly its size was now incorrect to whatever its connected to. The breaker is your last line of defense before the wiring starts to melt and the fire begins. If your airplane is wired correctly the breaker will do it's job, but if it's not, repeatedly pushing the breaker in, or worse yet holding it in is just asking for a fire.
My airplane is now wired correctly, and everything electrical has its own dedicated circuit breaker, of the proper amperage, and the wiring is the proper amperage. Bigrenna went through the same thing when he refurbed his plane. Others here have as well I'm sure. We can now trust our electrical system and its protection. Most everyone else, probably not.
In the rare instance when an electrical short exists that can't be located by removing equipment, or checking the obvious potential problem areas, you can locate it with a handheld magnetic compass and an automatic resetting circuit breaker (of the correct amperage for the circuit). Remove the wires connected to the circuit breaker in the panel, attach them to the auto-resetting breaker. Power up and the breaker will pop, reset, pop, reset, pop, reset, etc. Move the compass around throughout the aircraft near the wiring. Away from the location of the short the compass needle will show a big deflection every time the breaker pops. As you get near the short the deflections will decrease.
Oh, my wife has had two cars that had electrical fires (both Toyotas). In both cases all the fire department could do was contain the blaze until the wiring burned itself completely through. And that was long after the car's interiors were completely destroyed by the fires.