Wed Nov 23, 2011 11:26 am
I started looking in Sep 2010 for a plane, and looked at virtually every 170B/180/182 advertised on the market in the U.S. The 182 was (and is) undervalued compared to the other two models I mentioned. Not sure of the reasoning, but that's what the data looked like to me. Given my desire for a 4-place (2 really), instrument equipped hauler, and the fact that I'm 6'4" and used to be over 270 (now in the 220's - cheapest way to take out of the plane!), it narrowed down to those choices (the 170B's I was looking at had 180hp engines). If I generalized, the markets for the 170Bs with the larger engines started in the mid $40's and went to the $70's, the 180's started at the low $50's and went to the low $100's (I didn't look at anything newer than '62 or so on the 180's). When I turned to the 182's, the market actually shifted to the left, with prices ranging from the high $20's to the low $70's (model years '65 and older). I bought the 182 Buyer's Guide from CPA which helped me make choices in terms of my search (I wanted a straight tail and manual flaps; IFR; updated panel).
FWIW, I never really 172's in my search as the smaller engine and cabin made it less desirable for me. However, there is SIGNIFICANT overlap in the market for 172's and 182's from a price perspective that is not reflective of the difference in capabilities (payload, cruising speed, etc.) . . .
I bought my '58 182A the week it came on the market in Jan 2011. It had most of what I was looking for (but no STOL or long range tanks), was very competitively priced, had been actively flown by the previous owner, and had a ton of upgrades he had put in it over the 20+ year's he'd owned the plane, telling me that it was a plane that had been loved. Plus it had been PPonked with a 3blade prop (looks sexy just standing still on the ramp!).
So my $.02 (and it's not worth that much!) is that the 182 market is definitely undervalued - if you look hard and deep, you'll find a plane that will do everything you want it to do, and save $20-30,000 in the process compared to some of the other options available to you. And the 182 is MUCH less likely to bite you in the arse in flight operations - all in all a very docile platform. OMMV, but you can't go wrong with a 182 . . .
Cheers,
SH