Zzz wrote:...What if you're not in a stalled condition because you're holding it on, tail high, to build up speed? Then the gust lifts a wing?
I get the high AOA condition use of rudder, and when a wheel is on the ground, obviously rudder is paramount. But in response to a gusty wing lift at low AOA? Kinda just...everything? In the video of Swirly Girl, the gust seems to have lifted the left wing, and zooming in shows a pretty hard right rudder as you suggest. He also then swerves to the right a little. So, trying to stay out of the water as long as possible while staying at low AOA to build speed to fly... seems he did ok?
I can't criticize Andrew's thoughts and approach to the situation as I wasn't there. Run the video you took with the slowest motion speed YouTube offers (O.25 in the Setting menu):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bzYexqe ... u.be&t=400 Back it up, go forward, stop, and evaluate what you see.
As far as the rudder while still in ground contact there are limits to what can be done versus ground track and side loads on the gear. I'm not sure what was his intended ground track rudder wise but it was wagging left and right until the right wing lifted. When slowed in replay we see his attempt to mainly pin tires on the bar, and perhaps as an unintended consequence the right wing with down aileron lifted first...wind gust? higher lift and AOA outboard? His call as I don't know which direction the wind was predominately from prior to and during takeoff.
It then appears he neutralized the ailerons, dropped the left briefly, then reset neutral and used right rudder after the left tire quit skidding left (it's rolled over some) and went airborne. He had bar left when the right wing first lifted. Good save at the end and nice documentary. Must have been fun on a nice day.
One common failure for Taylorcraft gear is via repeated excessive side load compression. The diagonal strut on this plane has the mid-span reinforcement but the lower end is susceptible to internal corrosion and requires frequent inspection for debris and trueness.
Gary