I used David Clark headsets for many years, in working airplanes. Then, ANR started appearing. I used the early Bose (very heavy) headsets for a while, and they were fine. When the Bose X came out, one of our pilots put them in his assigned airplane. I flew that plane one day, and within an hour I literally had to take the headset off....earcups are too small for my ears.
I went to Lightspeed, and have now graduated to Lightspeed Zulus...three, I think. I have used them in work airplanes for years, and in my personal airplanes. I much prefer them to any other brand.
Being a long time admirer of David Clark company, I purchased a pair of their latest ANR headset a couple of years ago. It was awful, and after using it for ten hours or so, I called DC and got a return authorization. They refunded my purchase price. They are that kind of company, as others have noted here. I just didn't like the fit of the headset, and the ANR wasn't anywhere near as good as the Lightspeed Zulu in my experience.
So, frankly, that's the problem with headsets: Our heads and our ears are NOT all the same. You are going to have to figure out what works for you.....ALL the major headset manufacturers make great headsets....Bose, David Clark and Lightspeed, in my experience.
But differences in head shape, ears, and, importantly, the Aircraft you're flying, all contribute to what works best for YOU.
So, I can tell you what works for me. You'll have to try the headset and decide if it's what you prefer.
I can tell you, however, that both David Clark and Lightspeed offer some of the best customer service in any industry. Hands down. I had a problem with a Lightspeed Zulu cord set at OSH. Went to their exhibit booth to ask about it. They said bring the headset to them. They took a cord set off a headset they were using as a demo, and installed it on my headset....no charge.
But, what works for you.....you'll need to figure out. You won't go wrong with either DC or Lightspeed, though.
MTV