Zzz wrote:I think this thread could have stayed more on track if it had been titled "mechanical self-reliance in the bush."
We talk survival and bushcraft etc quite a bit but aircraft repair technique, or makeshift repairs, or toolkit could avoid having to use skills from the former discipline.
It did sort of go all over the place, but the original post really wasn't about mechanical issues...just being able to take care of what comes up while out and about without having to call for help. I personally think it's sort of funny that some of the suggestions were "just be able to call for help". Handy as that option is, it's pretty much the opposite of being self reliant.
Mechanical issues are nearly impossible to address across the board. There's so much that could go wrong, and such a vast discrepancy between individual pilots' mechanical abilities. Tools and parts are heavy enough that carrying more than you absolutely have to "just in case" is not a viable strategy. If weight and space wasn't an issue I'd cary a lot of things...including a mounted spare tire, like all my cars have.
There's also the HUGE issue of knowing what you can jerry-rig and what you can't. I read the accident report of a 185 where the cable that holds the tip of the ski came detached in flight. The resulting yaw when the ski went from horizontal to vertical instantly tore the airplane into half a dozen pieces. A person seeing a soon-to-break connection on their ski cable would be well advised not to fix it with epoxy and safety wire, though that seems like a perfectly good option if you didn't know the consequences of failure.
On the other hand I read about a guy who landed on a lake and noticed that there were only two screws holding the cowling onto his 180. How he ended up in that situation is a topic to itself, but in the end he spent the day whittling willow branches into makeshift screws and flew home...the cowling was completely secure when he landed. Whether or not that was smart I don't really know.
I think "maintain the hell out of it at home" is really the only logical strategy for ensuring a mechanically sound aircraft. After that I think most of a persons success or failure rests on how creative they are and their mechanical knowledge much more than what's in their tool box. But jerry-rigging without a keen understanding of what you're working on is probably worse than just waiting for rescue.
Fixing a flat tire is a legitimate concern, as anyone can get a flat in the field. I cary a patch kit and a bicycle pump, and my tool kit has what I need to remove and split the wheel. That's a few ounces. I don't cary a jack and adaptor and tube...thats a dozen pounds. NOT worth it, in my opinion. I'm a reasonably clever guy and I've got several ideas for how to lift a gear leg...whether I'll be able to harvest the material on site to make it work or not is yet to be seen.
Digging out under the tire...On a heavy Cessna I have a hard time seeing it working. The gear moves so much and there's very little area for the shoring to support. Maybe build a frame and hang the leg from above, then dig out from below. Regardless, I'd much rather spend a day trying that than push the Help button on my Spot.
Good mention on the Stan's Sealant. I personally have not found it to work well with tubes, but I still run it, and I add more a couple times a year to keep it fresh.